'Bachelor in Paradise' Episode 5 Recap: Allyshia Ruffles Some Feathers for Kat & Dale — Paradise After Dark

Paradise After Dark is the unofficial late-night aftershow of Bachelor in Paradise 2025, and in this episode 4 recap, Stefanie and Jackie are rehashing: Allyshia's arrival that seriously ruffles feathers (pun intended) The continued drama between Kat and Dale Lea and Jonathon's date — did they hook up prior to this season? The very bizarre chemistry test Jeremy confiding in Brian about his feelings for Susie Parisa and Brian fighting in the VIP suite over Brian's favorite color Jill's unfortunate self elimination (PLUS, stick around until the end for some fun discussion about Backstreet Boys vs. NSYNC and the latest news about Justin Timberlake's concerts where he barely sings.) Watch this episode on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@shesallbach Thanks to Honeylove for sponsoring this episode. Treat yourself to the most comfortable and innovative bras on the market and save 20% off site-wide at Honeylove.com/SHESALLBACH20.